1
Misc. Naval Games / Re: Prinz Eugen mini-campaig
« on: April 08, 2022, 11:08:31 pm »
I’m not sure PE could get away.. she’s probably not in top form and could only manage 32kts compared to say the S Class destroyers 36kts. Savage or Iroquis could easily shadow PE and stay out of Torp range if Dido / Devonshire couldn’t quite keep up (although they can both match PEs speed)
Also I don’t think you can underplay (as has been said) the importance of Radar. Gone are the days of slipping into a fog bank.
So I think its an intriguing idea, but ultimately PE and Nurnberg, even if they were somehow able to get BVR would still be doomed. Without her main armament PE is a sitting duck, Devonshire and Iroquois could pop away all day at her from outside of Torpedo range if they felt like it.
One other thing, is while PE’s crew would be running for their freedom (or so they thought), The RN crews don’t have any love for the Kreigsmarine at this point and I’m not sure they would be particularly restrained in prosecuting an attack.
Thats my tuppence worth.. was an interesting thought experiment tho
G.
Also I don’t think you can underplay (as has been said) the importance of Radar. Gone are the days of slipping into a fog bank.
So I think its an intriguing idea, but ultimately PE and Nurnberg, even if they were somehow able to get BVR would still be doomed. Without her main armament PE is a sitting duck, Devonshire and Iroquois could pop away all day at her from outside of Torpedo range if they felt like it.
One other thing, is while PE’s crew would be running for their freedom (or so they thought), The RN crews don’t have any love for the Kreigsmarine at this point and I’m not sure they would be particularly restrained in prosecuting an attack.
Thats my tuppence worth.. was an interesting thought experiment tho
G.